A shift is underway in investor psychology that is upending the software sector. The stock market is increasingly drawing a hard distinction between companies built natively around artificial intelligence and those attempting to retrofit AI into legacy workflows. For the latter group, no amount of branding, bolt-on features, or incremental upgrades is convincing Wall Street that they can sustain their moats. The emerging consensus is unforgiving: if a task is generic and repeatable, AI will soon outperform purpose-built software, leaving behind even the most entrenched incumbents.
Adobe’s Firefly, Salesforce’s Einstein, and Intuit’s TurboTax AI copilots are prime examples of this dilemma. All three companies have added AI features, but investors sense they are enhancements layered onto traditional offerings rather than reinventions of the products themselves. The skepticism is evident in valuations, where these names no longer command the growth premiums they once enjoyed. Trade Desk, once synonymous with algorithmic ad-buying, now competes against AI platforms that can not only purchase ad space but also generate campaigns, measure results, and reallocate spend in real time—threatening the very need for intermediaries. DocuSign’s once-unassailable niche of digital signatures feels small in a world where AI systems can draft, negotiate, and execute agreements end-to-end. Zoom, which once seemed indispensable, is increasingly at risk of becoming just a utility layer, as AI-native collaboration platforms offer not just video calls but automatic summarization, task assignment, and contextual knowledge sharing.
The pressure is mounting for project management companies as well, where the very act of coordinating tasks is becoming a prime target for AI disruption. Atlassian’s Jira and Confluence, Asana, Smartsheet, ClickUp, and Monday.com are all under the microscope. Their value propositions center on structuring workflows, assigning responsibilities, and visualizing progress—activities that generalized AI agents can handle with greater fluidity. Instead of manually updating boards or assigning tasks, AI copilots embedded in productivity suites can monitor conversations, interpret priorities, and dynamically allocate work without human input. Monday.com’s colorful dashboards, once a differentiator, risk being commoditized by AI workspaces that combine project planning, document drafting, communication, and analytics in one seamless interface. The narrative emerging among investors is that specialized project management platforms may soon be redundant, swallowed by intelligent, always-on digital assistants that coordinate projects automatically across tools.
This dynamic extends beyond office productivity. Dropbox and Box, early leaders in cloud file storage, now struggle against AI-native competitors that integrate storage, search, and content generation. Workday and ServiceNow, cornerstones of enterprise HR and IT workflows, are increasingly questioned as to whether their functions will endure once AI systems can handle onboarding, payroll, IT troubleshooting, and workflow escalation in natural language. Shopify, a darling of e-commerce enablement, faces pressure as AI-driven commerce tools automate not only storefront creation but also inventory, marketing, and customer service.
The consequence is a brutal repricing: markets are stripping away premiums from software firms that are seen as “AI-adjacent” while rewarding those that are AI-first. Investors are not punishing execution—many of these firms remain profitable, with strong customer bases—but they are punishing irrelevance. The perception is that bolt-on AI features cannot protect them against disruption from AI-native entrants.
Unlike the SaaS, mobile, or cloud transitions, where layering features was enough to stay competitive, AI demands a re-architecture of the entire product. Investors increasingly treat it as binary: either the company is AI-core, or it is vulnerable. That is why Nvidia, Palantir, and firms building foundational AI platforms are showered with capital, while Adobe, Salesforce, Intuit, Trade Desk, DocuSign, Zoom, Monday.com, Atlassian, Asana, and others are under a valuation squeeze. The message is stark—AI is not just a feature. It is the future of software. Those who fail to embody it at their core will be left behind.
Would you like me to strengthen this piece further by adding financial context—for example, how multiples, P/E ratios, or market caps have diverged between AI-first companies and legacy software firms? That could make the article more investor-focused.